Is Grace & Stella 'Cool Girl' Skincare Actually Worth The Hype?
An honest review of the internet's latest skincare obsession
The Beauty Ed®’s Note: As a beauty journalist with over 25 years experience, I have witnessed how the ‘viral skincare’ trend has changed how we shop. But let’s be honest, looking cute on camera doesn’t always equate to cute results on the skin. And when the Grace & Stella PR asked THE LAB to try some of their products, I couldn’t think of a better person than my brilliant contributor Paloma Sedeno. I wanted her to give this ‘cool girl’ brand an honest, real-skin test. And that she did…
Beyond the pretty packaging: can a ‘cool-girl’ brand actually deliver high-performance skincare results?
Grace & Stella might just be the next viral skincare brand, so when their products landed on my desk, I was obviously going to put them to the test.
I got sent their eye patches (as seen on Emily Blunt in The Devil Wears Prada 2, mind you) and their *adorable* pimple patches. I’m a sucker for anything that looks fun, so they really had me from the get-go.
The Overnight Fix: Testing the Internet’s Favorite Pimple Patches
I feel like I’ve tried every pimple patch out there since the Starface ones became super popular in 2020. While my go-to pimple patches are usually whatever is the best value from Amazon, the Grace & Stella ones piqued my interest because they are SO cute - sue me, I’m easily influenced.
The Ingredient Upgrade: More Than Just Hydrocolloid
Most pimple patches are just standard hydrocolloid patches that draw out the oil and gunk from your blemishes. On top of that, the Grace & Stella ones also contain Salicylic Acid (which reduces swelling) and Tea Tree Oil (an antiseptic to combat acne bacteria and speed up healing).
The added ingredients make these super effective not only at calming the redness of angry blemishes but also at reducing their size and drawing them out of the skin more quickly. Since going on Accutane a few years ago, my skin has definitely improved and I don’t get nearly as many blemishes as I used to but I do get the odd pimple here and there. These patches are so aesthetic that they almost make you want to get a pimple just so you can use them, so I was actually quite delighted to get to test them out.
I’m a pimple patch overnight girl, and by the time I had woken up, the redness and swelling had gone down, and with a little dab of concealer, it was like there was nothing wrong in the first place.
The Prime Day Verdict: The best part is that the patches are included in the Amazon Prime sale from the 23rd-26th June and are nearly 15% off!!
The £0.83 Pamper: Putting the Viral Eye Masks to the Test
As an avid beauty fan, the first thing I noticed about these eye masks is the number of pairs you get in a single box - 24! For a little comparison, Sephora’s best-selling eye masks are the Topicals ones, which come in a pack of 6 pairs for £20 ($22 in the US!), which comes to around £3.30 per use. BUT, the Grace & Stella masks are currently £20 for 24 pairs, which is around £0.83 per use. So it’s pretty clear to see which ones are the most cost-efficient. Okay, maths lesson OVER, let’s get into the eye masks themselves.
Grace & Stella are really spoiling us with 6 different kinds of eye masks to try! Energising, moisturising, restoring, firming, illuminating and revitalising - I received the illuminating ones (which were actually the perfect selection because I am noticing dark circles at the ripe age of 22).
When I first received these, I put a pair straight into the fridge because I just knew that the added coolness would upgrade the experience, and I was right (shock!) It also made me wonder if I should invest in one of those skincare fridges for my bedroom, but that may be taking things too far, even for me.
The Application Test: Do They Actually Stay Put?
Anyway, when I tried them the next morning, one thing that immediately stood out to me was that they weren’t slipping down my face every five seconds (huge win!) and the cooling effect made me feel de-puffed and more awake. While you definitely don’t need a pair of eye masks every day, they feel like a little treat when you want an elevated morning routine, or a pamper night in.
The Beauty Ed® Approved: The Honest Verdict
It’s hard to cut through the noise in the beauty industry, but I think Grace & Stella have done just that. Not only are their products effective and cute, but they also come at a reasonable price point that doesn’t make you dread your restock.
Here is how they stack up:
Grace & Stella Pimple Patches Verdict
Best For: Overnight blemish healing and calming acute inflammation without stripping the skin barrier.
The Experience: Somehow, these pimple patches strike the perfect balance; they stay put firmly on your spots, but they are gentle to take off. I find that some pimple patches that look playful, like this, aren’t always the most focused on skincare, but the Tea Tree Oil and Salicylic Acid in these give you genuine results. I have no complaints (and I’m a Virgo, so that’s pretty rare!)
Grace & Stella Illuminating Eye Masks Verdict
Best For: A cost-effective, cooling luxury treatment to de-puff the under-eyes and prep skin for makeup.
The Experience: I don’t know that I noticed a huge difference visually, but as a pampering treatment, they definitely made my morning routine feel a little more luxurious, and they feel amazing on my under eyes. I’d also definitely repurchase these over other brands I’ve tried; they’re cost-efficient, look good and feel fabulous.
Now, please excuse me while I scroll the rest of their website, adding to my wishlist!
P xx
Such a gorgeously detailed review ✨